I had a similar issue with my truck. I tuned mine to run at 14.1 afr due to ethanol fuel and at idle mine would always want to run rich. I mean real rich. if you would idle it over 2 minutes the afr would drop to 12 and it would stumble. I found that if I adjusted the mv on the o2 sensor the afr would change accordingly. higher voltage = richer afr. currently in closed loop I'm running 14.1 afr with the 02 rich lean mv set at 855 and its working like a charm for me. I'm fairly new to tuning but its what worked for me (senior tuners feel free to chime in and correct me if I'm wrong by doing this) but I am going to try the integrator adjustment this eavning. but open loop tuning I had the afr dialed in at 14.1 and when I renabled closed loop it leaned out to 15.3 no matter what changes I made to maf and ve tables.